Skip to Sidebar Skip to Content

Pantone's Next Color Is a Trap for Small Brands

Pantone's Next Color Is a Trap for Small Brands
Image by Christina Rumpf

On December 1, Pantone will announce its 2027 Color of the Year, and the guessing has already started. In a Forbes survey of design professionals, "22 of the 55 experts queried predicted a shade of green, the most of any color chosen."

Within weeks of the announcement, the winning color will show up on packaging, Instagram grids, and refreshed landing pages. For a large company, it is a cheap seasonal campaign. For a small brand that recolors its identity to match, it can quietly undo years of work on being recognized.

Pantone sells a moment, not a brand

Pantone has picked a color of the year since 1999, starting with a muted blue called Cerulean for 2000. The selection is presented as cultural forecasting. Commercially, it works as a launch platform.

When Pantone named Cloud Dancer, an off-white, for 2026, the partner list was ready on day one. Marketech APAC reported a special-edition Motorola phone "as part of its multi-year partnership with Pantone," a Play-Doh edition, a Post-it collection, Mandarin Oriental spa treatments, and a Joybird furniture line in "more than 300 silhouettes."

Those partners used the color as a limited edition, something that runs for a season and then ends. None of them changed their logo.

Fashion items don't build memory

The research case against chasing the trend comes from the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute for Marketing Science, where Jenni Romaniuk has spent years studying how buyers recognize brands. She defines the goal plainly: "Distinctiveness is looking like you and not like others."

Romaniuk splits a brand's recognizability into specific elements, "colours, logos and names," and warns against treating any of them as seasonal. "The one thing I'm trying to push is that you don't want your distinctive assets to be fashion items," she told Contagious.

A trend color undermines distinctiveness in both directions. It makes you look like the hundreds of other businesses that adopted the same shade that month, and it leaves your customers' memory of your old color with nothing to attach to.

What Cadbury knows that trend-chasers don't

Cadbury shows how much a single color can be worth. The company trademarked Pantone 2685C, its purple, in 1995. It then fought Nestlé over the scope of that mark for years, until the UK Court of Appeal rejected its attempt to widen it in 2018.

Even after losing that round, Cadbury still owns the purple for chocolate bars and tablets. Its parent, Mondelēz, said it was "disappointed with this decision." A company does not spend more than two decades in court over a color that matters only for one season.

Most small businesses will never trademark a shade. The same principle still applies at any size: a color you use consistently becomes a shortcut customers use to recognize you, and that shortcut takes years to build.

The trend is a signal, not a spec

None of this means ignoring Pantone. The Color of the Year is a useful read on mood, and this year's predictions say something. Erin Remington of the Los Angeles firm A Finer Eye told Forbes, "I think we're moving beyond the more familiar, softer shades of green." Dominic Tyler of Sydney's Next Level Painting pointed to "a good sense of psychological stability associated with olive green."

That reading fits a year of nervous markets and tariff-driven price increases. When Pantone chose white for 2026, an Instagram user quoted by Smithsonian joked that "the color of the year being colorless is a recession indicator." People read these picks as commentary on the economy, and a small brand can borrow that conversation without changing its identity.

The practical rule is to separate your brand into two layers.

The core layer covers your logo color, primary palette, typeface, and packaging structure. It stays fixed. Changes happen only for strategic reasons, and they happen gradually.

The campaign layer covers seasonal social templates, holiday packaging sleeves, a limited product run, event signage, and email headers. It can wear the color of the year for a quarter and then return to normal.

A quick test before adopting any trend color: show a customer your product with the logo covered. If the new color makes it harder for them to tell it is yours, it belongs in the campaign layer, not the core.

What this means for 2027

Expect December to bring a wave of "refreshed" small-business brands in green, along with agencies selling the update. The brands that benefit most will run a well-timed limited edition, collect the attention, and keep their identity unchanged.

That is the advantage small companies have over large ones. Large companies need Pantone partnerships to create a news moment. A small company can respond in a week with a capsule product, a seasonal post or a holiday package sleeve, without the multi-year contract.

Pantone picks one color a year. Your brand needs to stay recognizable for the next ten years, so treat the 2027 color as a campaign option and keep your core identity as it is.

Zilck Team Zilck Team
Navigate effortlessly between news, knowledge and entertainment.

Become a Member Now

Join Zilck Pro today and unlock all content.